or, Emotions and Your Average White Guy.
honeybeemeadows, I hope you like this one.
I've been thinking recently about a music article I once saw that basically made the statement that Bright Eyes was too "gay." It was Esquire (which kalinichta tells me has now changed its tune, probably because old Conor has decided to look more unambiguously male and less like a delicate androgyno elf child), but that's not important. Every major music publication (that isn't ... whichever one did the loving spread of unshaven Coberst) has the token "OMG BRYTE EYEZES SOOO GEEEEH!" article.
Mocking Coberst for his "gayness" is more or less ubiquitous for anyone with any kind of indie proclivity. Sometimes it's kind of funny (see the Uncyclopedia article, which had me in stitches throughout), but mostly it's kind of depressing.
Conor Oberst likes women. He does like some men, but in case you haven't been around me and witnessed my similar relationship to "heterosexuality", I do not find this unusual or strange at all; I also don't think a person should be defined by their sexuality, nor
that a person's sexuality defines THEM.
But the funny part is, more or less, the dude likes girls. The dude is, in fact, "straight."
So why the fuss over "the gay"? Why the dismissal of his discography as a bunch of whiny drivel?
Okay, yes. I've listened to 'Water' (one time, which is minutes of my life I will never get back). I waded through 'A Collection of Songs Written And Recorded.' Some of his shit IS whiny drivel. We can't expect a whole lot different from a white boy from an NPR family who grew up in Omaha in the early nineties. It's really no different from anything most kids write when they're ages thirteen through eighteen, except the rhyme scheme is occasionally classier.
So is hating Coberst for his teen works perhaps a bit of self-hatred, O Indie-merica? Do you so loathe your awkward, silly, angsty young self that you must paint all others with the same brush? Fact of life, angst is basically a phase we all go through and must learn to laugh off. Laugh off 'Water.' Coberst himself has.
Something unexpected happened in the early 2000s. Conor Oberst stopped writing so much about girls not liking him (although he did write a lot about that too, which I will touch on shortly) and turned his angst on his dissatisfaction with his sense of self, the status quo, Western civilization, etc.
This is a theme that has continued through to Cassadaga, and on to the Mystic Valley Band as well. The kid has had some smart things to say. Really smart, eloquent things. Less so when he was 22, of course, but even then his use of metaphors was pretty good.
If most people feel that expressing dissatisfaction with the status quo and the limited roles that society enforces upon each of us is mere whining, then why do I even bother to get out of bed?
If you both agree with and see the delicious humor in that statement, consider us on the same side.
Does the average dude who listens to indie rock consider the expression of emotion to be 'gay'? I think they do. I think Conor Oberst thinks they do. I think neither he nor I can be arsed to give a flying fuck. Coberst emotes all over the fucking place, whenever he goddamn feels like it, but he brings with it a depth, a concern, a sense of questioning that elevates it above the average emo band (most of the time). That, I suspect, is somewhat of a radical act.
Judging by the typical white-dude response to Conor Oberst, it is.
"He's a faggot." For expressing tenderness? For admitting to sadness? For refusing to languish in ennui? For confessing that he desires love?
Ah, love. Conor Oberst and girls. Conor Oberst has done a lot of whining about girls, and that is for sure. Genuine whining. And a lot of other times, he's just plain missed the fucking boat. I do wonder if he has ever grasped the concept that, for all he dislikes the
constraints he feels as a white dude, women have that + 1,000,000. A lot of his disciples, like my ex Danny, fail to see that point by about a mile. We may never know what Conor really thinks.
However, sometimes there is a glimmer of getting it that I see through the fog of obliviousness. Coberst writes about, among other things, letting women soullessly fuck him just out of his desire to please them. Whoa, an experience I can relate to! Hey there, Coberst, can you then use this feeling in terms of empathy, and thus actually relate to
a female person?! I see a possibility there, which I do not see in most dudes. By which I mean, indie dudes, because there are no other kinds of dudes that I even bother gifting with my attention.
So thus, clearly, Conor Oberst is gay. He can empathize with women (maybe). Proof positive of Teh Gay. I don't even think I have to write any more about it.
Other than the fact that my queer male-female transgendered former roommate looooooved "Teh Coberst". That's another dead giveaway right there.
Dixie and I both felt that, for all the sleeping with women that Coberst does or did, and the voting for Obama (as opposed to Dennis Kucinich, his logical soulmate and the dude he will probably become when he gets older) that he encouraged, the guy crosses a lot of what society takes for granted are boundaries. Without even seeming to think about it. It's just what he does.
If anything, I wish he did it MORE. I wish he took it EVEN FURTHER.